Friday, August 16, 2013

CITATION SYSTEMS: WHICH DO YOU PREFER?


Citation Systems
Which is the best?

There are several distinct conventions authors can use to cite the sources they use in their research.  Individuals often have very strong beliefs about which convention is best.  And professional organizations have issued lengthy guidelines.  Among the best known and most widely used are those of the American Psychological Association, the Modern Language Association, and the University of Chicago Press.  Some research journals have their own systems. 

Is one of these better than the others?  No, they are all just fine.  They are all merely conventions.  Saying that one is better than another would be like claiming that driving on the left side of the road is better than driving on the right.  Both are fine as long as everyone knows and abides by the rules.   

There is only one criterion for excellence in a citation system.  If your reader can easily check your sources for accuracy, the system is good.  If your reader cannot do so, the system is bad.  Specific format does not matter at all if it meets this criterion. 

But tastes differ, people have preferences.  As an author of text books and reference works in research methods, I wanted to know what my readers prefer.  So I did some market research among potential readers—students in research methods courses in the social sciences and applied disciplines such as nursing, social work, and education.  I prepared two versions of a short paragraph, one citing sources in parentheses in the text of the paragraph and the other citing the sources in footnotes or endnotes. 

The results were overwhelming.  In the first group of 47 students surveyed, 42 preferred the endnote system, 5 didn’t care, and not a single student opted for the in-text citation system.  In psychology courses, the in-text citation system did better, probably because the American Psychological Association uses an in-text system, and it is a powerful presence in the fields of psychology and education.  But in no group of respondents did more than 20% ever opt for an in-text system.  Readers who offered an explanation said that in-text citations were “annoying,” that they “got in the way,” and that they “cluttered the text.” 

Convinced by this market research, I have used footnotes or endnotes for citations whenever possible. 


HERE ARE THE SURVEY INSTRUCTIONS FOLLOWED BY THE TWO VERSIONS OF THE PARAGRAPH

I would appreciate your help with the following survey.  I am writing text books and
reference works for graduate students in research methods, and I would like to learn from potential readers your preferences about the format of the text.

The survey is anonymous.  You are under no obligation to participate.  If you choose not to participate just return these pages blank.

Thank you,
W. Paul Vogt
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The passages on the next page are identical in content, but they differ in form.  The first version of the passage includes the citations in the text.  The second version provides the citations as endnotes.

WHICH DO YOU PREFER?
If you were consulting a reference book or text book, which of the two passages would you rather read?


_____Version 1 with citations in the text


_____Version 2 with citations as endnotes


_____No preference


If you would be willing to share the reasons for your preferences, please explain them below.  I would appreciate learning about them. 


Version 1—Citations in Text

While internet surveys are becoming more common, many scholars (Baker, Curtice & Sparrow, 2002; Schoen & Fass, 2005; see also Couper, 2000; Dillman, 2000) continue to express skepticism about their value, especially as concerns sampling bias.  On the other hand, several survey experiments comparing Internet surveying to more traditional modes (Krosnick & Chang, 2001; VanBeselaere, 2002; Alvarez, Sherman & VanBeselaere, 2003; Chang & Krosnik, 2003; Sanders, Clarke, Stewart, & Whiteley, 2007) have shown that well-conducted Internet surveys can be as effective as other methods of sampling and surveying.

Version 2—Citations in Endnotes

While internet surveys are becoming more common, many scholars[1] continue to express skepticism about their value, especially as concerns sampling bias.  On the other hand, several survey experiments comparing Internet surveying to more traditional modes[2]  have shown that well-conducted Internet surveys can be as effective as other methods of sampling and surveying.




[1] Baker, Curtice & Sparrow, 2002;  Schoen & Fass, 2005.  See also Couper, 2000;  Dillman, 2000.

[2] Krosnick & Chang, 2001; VanBeselaere, 2002; Alvarez, Sherman & VanBeselaere, 2003; Chang & Krosnik, 2003;  Sanders, Clarke, Stewart, & Whiteley, 2007.



IF YOU HAVE A REASON FOR PREFERRING ONE VERSION OR THE OTHER, AND YOU WOULD LIKE TO SHARE IT, PLEASE POST IT BELOW.   

26 comments:

  1. If there are only a few references I don't mind to put the in the text. But with a few, I mean 3 or less per page!

    In any other situation - and that would be any academic writing, given you'll have more than 3 references per page - I'd go for footnotes, given it makes the text more readable.
    I prefer footnotes over endnotes, because if you do want to see the source, you don't need to go back and forth to the endnotes.

    Best,
    Dennis Bours
    http://www.linkedin.com/in/dpbours/

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dennis,
    I agree completely. Publishers used to balk at footnotes, but modern typesetting technology makes it no more complicated to put footnotes where they belong. At least Guilford Press, where I've published my most recent work, has no problem with putting footnotes at the foot of the page, where readers usually want them.
    Paul

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Paul! Call me crazy, but I've been reading academic literature in the social sciences for so long now that I have developed a strong preference for APA in-text citations, and find it a pain to go hunting for endnotes. It's also the only style I've used for writing since high school, and THAT as we know was done with a pen and paper! :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sheila,
      I agree with you about endnotes, but footnotes, especially, those at the foot of the page, combine the virtues of non-cluttered text with not having to hunt for endnotes.
      I grew up on Turabian's (University of Chicago) style, but I've become a polyglot citation speaker--whatever the publisher or journal wants I'll give.
      One the thing about the APA style I don't like is replacing names with initials. Seems so impersonal.
      Paul

      Delete
  4. Hi this is babu, I want to share some information for you,If you want to join any professional course visit this website
    java training in chennai It's a best place to learn java trainig in chennai
    thanks, babu

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for sharing this valuable information to our vision
    Dot net training

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for sharing your view to our knowledge’s, its helps me plenty keep sharing…
    Salesforce training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for splitting your comprehension with us. It’s really useful to me & I hope it helps the people who in need of this vital information.
    Angular training in chennai|Angular course in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, I wish to be a regular contributor of your blog. I have read your blog. Your information is really useful for us. I did Software Testing Training at Fita training and placement academy which offer best Software Testing Course in Chennai with years of experienced professionals. This is really useful for me to make a bright career.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Your blog is really nice and informative. Thanks for sharing this post. Keep posting..

    Regards..
    Salesforce Developer Training in Chennai




    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for sharing your innovative ideas..Its really useful and interesting...

    Regards...

    Salesforce.com Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi friends, This is Murali from Chennai. I am a technology freak. Your technical information is really useful for me. Keep update your blog.
    Regards..
    Best Oracle Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi, Your blog is really very informative and useful for me. Thanks for sharing this valuable blog.
    Regards..
    Unix Training Institutes in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a compain of the nursing studies.Whether you are presently working in the healthcare field or wish to do so, you can make a wise decision to study for your healthcare online nursing degree program
    and nursing degree online.Look for an online nursing program that is offered by a school that is accredited by the top nursing associations

    ReplyDelete
  14. Survey analysis is often presumed to be difficult - the reality may not be so. Survey analysis in a survey research can be classified into two - quantitative and qualitative data analysis. This article tries to throw light on the basic differences between the two techniques. See more statistical analysis of survey data

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

  16. What an awesome post, I just read it from start to end. Learned something new after a long time.

    AWS training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thanks for sharing your innovative ideas..Its really useful and interesting...
    silverlight training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  18. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful to me...
    Android Training in Chennai
    Ios Training in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  19. Amazing Article ! I have bookmarked this article page as i received good information from this. All the best for the upcoming articles. I will be waiting for your new articles. Thank You ! Kindly Visit Us @ Coimbatore Travels | Ooty Travels | Coimbatore Airport Taxi

    ReplyDelete
  20. Well with your permission let me grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million, and please keep up the gratifying work.
    fire and safety course in chennai

    ReplyDelete